← Main Menu  |  Book Contents  |  ← Chapter 5  |  Chapter 6  |  Chapter 7 →

The Rise and Fall of The NEW Four Seasons 1966 to 1977

Chapter 6 — December 1976 (Oh! What A Year)

Bob Gaudio had commented back at Motown in 1972 that the music business was all about the ‘Album’ and a strong set of track, and here he was after a session that had generated a superb backing track for the ‘returning’ Frankie Valli to set the standard for the Fall 1975 ‘follow on’ sessions for an album.

Chapter image 1
Chapter image 2Chapter image 3

Above: clips from the Who Loves You ‘promo’ video

Watch the video here

The session for the ‘Who Loves You’ backing track had also included a song penned back at Motown by Bob Gaudio called ‘We Had It All(Walking In The Sunshine)’ which only survived without a ‘lead vocal’. It remains a mystery as to whether a vocal version survives on tape. But we have the ‘instrumental/backing vocals version’. The reason for this session was that Valli was in England promoting 'My Eyes Adored You' on The Lulu Show on UK TV. He hastened his return because Mike Curb liked Don Ciccone's vocal and wanted to release the track. As for the album, which was part of the ‘Contract’ with CURB Records, it remained to be seen if Bob Gaudio could come up with a set of songs to match what was clearly going to be a hit. It was a whole new sound. A little known fact is that Don Ciccone wrote the middle section of the song, [“Who Loves You”] but got no credit for it…..and most people don't know that Charles Calello added the final touch. As Charles told us…

“It's funny that, in the mid 70's as I did 'My Eyes Adored You' and 'Swearin' To God' with Bob Crewe, and finished the 'Close-Up' album with Bob Gaudio, and on the "sweetening sessions", I also sweetened 'Who Loves You.' I didn't write the strings to that song, I just conducted it; however, it was only Gaudio and I in the studio.”

Lee Shapiro also recalls this contribution by Charlie…

“'Who Loves You' was my very first recorded ‘string arrangement’ with a real live orchestra. I was 22 yrs old. Charlie Calello conducted the session due to our tour schedule. Charlie later told me that he had asked Gaudio if he, (ie Charlie), had written the arrangement.…because… “Stylistically, he thought it sounded like his work. Not a note was changed in the final performance from the one I had prepared.”
“In 2006 I had the pleasure of hanging out with Charlie at the Frankie Valli sessions in NYC for the 'Romancing The '60s', his then latest album, where I told him he had been a mentor to me however unknowingly. He was flattered as was I by his comments. He is a master orchestrater. Although Michel Legrand was an influence….(The Umbrellas of Cherbourg is one of my all time favourites). Legrand's arrangements are inspirational. My main influences were Maurice Ravel, Michel Legrand, Thad Jones, Duke Ellington, Herbie Hancock, but my #1 learning experience stylistically was from Charlie Calello.”
Chapter image 4Chapter image 5

Studio session photos from the 'Who Loves You' promo video

The single 'Who Loves You' upon release immediately went gold, hitting #3 in Billboard on November 15th 1975 as the Four Seasons, (with John Paiva having replaced Joe Long in September 1975) and they prepared to go into the studio again to record the album. Rex Woodard in a 1981 Goldmine article said….

“Gaudio fully expected Mike Curb to produce the album. Curb sensed Gaudio had lost a lot of confidence during the Motown years, but realised that Gaudio was the real 'soul' of the group (Valli being the 'sound'). Curb told Gaudio to produce the album and he obliged.”

Another late 70s article reported that ‘the big change’ was that Bob now had a new lyricist who had a modern and different perspective, his partner Judy Parker. She said of these times…

“I met Bob three years ago and, well, I can't really relate to the sense of 'Who Loves You' – the person singing seems really sad, really isolated, and that's not where Bob and I are at all. Bob's writing songs again and we're both very happy; still, though, things come out. The phrase 'Who Loves You' was something Bob just wanted to work with – that's how it started. The first line is always the hardest. Bob usually composes melodies on the piano, then tapes them and we just play them a lot, trying to find a feeling one of us can hash out into words. We like to take a little drive in the car and play the tapes while we drive – that seems to really help. Getting started is always the hardest part. But after that, Bob just takes everything and puts it into perspective. The more he works on a song, the easier it gets”.

Clearly Judy helped Bob's ideas to gel but how much she contributed to the song-writing process has been questioned by some. Unfairly, perhaps as she clearly helped him write, but her credit on songs was also a way of setting up the ‘royalties’ distribution.

The album ‘really’ was the creation of Bob and the Four Seasons ‘in the studio’. John Paiva described how the sessions developed.

“Bob brought in songs which always started on the piano. We developed things from there as a group. They were all simple 3 chord pop songs and we all just played them on to 24 multi-tracks so that the final masters could be mixed to give the track the right instrumental and vocal balance.”
“I recall that on 'Silver Star' I played on a rented 12 string guitar. I just played the chord sequence the way I saw it and the final mix brought that out as the feature sound behind Gerry's vocal.”
Chapter image 6

UK single sleeve for 'Silver Star' / 'Mystic Mr. Sam'

The track is as important for its instrumental arrangement which carries the vocal throughout. That guitar riff, Don's bass and Lee on the piano all give it a unique sound. The addition of horns and synth at key parts just lifts and 'sweetens' it. Frankie wasn't on the track. It would become the first major hit by the group to not feature him. The final mix ran to 6:05 secs on the album. This was the new sound of The NEW Four Seasons.

'Storybook Lovers' was originally the album opener but was finally moved to the second spot (first issue UK album artwork featured it still as the opening track). A simple 'laid-back' melody it features the group singing harmony with Valli in the main chorus with a musical arrangement featuring guitars, flutes, piano and strings giving the song a full, warm sound. This extension of the traditional group's harmonies prevalent in this track was a strong feature on the album. It was set for single release upon one occasion in the UK and would have done well in the UK charts at the time.

John Paiva recalls how one of the other key tracks on the album came together…..

“I recall doing a long solo on a track… 'Harmony, Perfect Harmony' and as I recall on Take 2 I got this solo done really well. It sounded good to me and I was happy with the improvisation and the rising chord sequence. Gerry Polci who was at the mixing board behind the screen dropped his headphones and came running around to say,”Man, that was great……you sounded just like George Benson”. The solo was used but disappointingly for me…..only the first part …..it was edited for the final master by Bob Gaudio just as the best bit….the rising chord sequence began”

On 'Emily's Salle De Danse' [ a ‘Club’ styled up-tempo song], John recalls how Bob Gaudio asked him and Lee to just improvise at the end and they thought the “jammin” would be simply edited out. But it stayed in as a 2 minute outro. A classic it remains.

Chapter image 7

Lee Shapiro's cartoon of John Paiva

'Mystic Mr. Sam' was a piano and Seasons harmony led track featuring Don Ciccone's vocal. It gave the group a chance to develop their own distinctive 'Seasons Sound'. The bluesy brass sets the 'blue-eyed soul' label that critics would give to this album.

But one track stood out and was included almost by accident as Goldmine reported in a 1984 interview with Don Ciccone:-

Chapter image 8

Don and John in the studio for the 'Who Loves You' sessions ‘promo’ video

“Goldmine: The next record, of course, was 'December 1963'. What was the story behind that?
Don Ciccone: It was a track on the album that followed 'Who Loves You'. It was originally titled 'December 5, 1933'. It was a completely different lyric. I can't be quoted on this, but I think it went “Oh What A Night/Flappers flippin' on the floor/People hollerin' for more/Pop them corks till your thumb gets sore”. Then was the chorus: “Oh why can't they change the colour of that yellow balloon/don't you think it's risin' much too soon”. Anyway, Bob Gaudio called a meeting of The Four Seasons and said he had heard through the grapevine that some of us were less than pleased with some of the music we were recording in the studio. He said “Now's the time to speak up because I don't want to be putting down voice and sweetening and have you guys be upset”.
Nobody would say anything but everybody had had severe criticisms in the hotel rooms when we were alone, without the 'brass'. Then he got to me and I said to myself, here we go again, I'm the fall guy. But I told him, “Bob, writer-to-writer, I've always been a big fan of your writing, you're a bigger success than I've been, but this tune, 'December 5, 1933' escapes me. Where in the hell are you coming from? It's a song about Prohibition. Kids have been in and out of the drug phase and now they're into healthy foods. What's the concept here?” And he said, “Clothing – '40s type clothing”. And I said, “Yeah, but flappers flipping' on the floor? They don't flip, they flap. That's why they're called flappers. Fish flip on the floor. And in the last verse you say “13 years of being dry”. Well, it was a 14-year dry era”.
There were little discrepancies within the song and it made him realise the song wasn't totally accurate. He got upset that I was bold enough to say anything. But if we had put that song out it would've been ripped to shreds by the critics. That made him angrier and I think he transferred his anger toward me. It separated Bob Gaudio and me; not on my behalf though.
But I remember Frankie saying to him “If you think Don has a good point with the lyrics, let Don take a shot at writing the lyrics”. So then Gaudio said, “Then the song is off the album”. Frankie said “We recorded the tracks and I'm telling you those are hit tracks. Why don't you give Don a shot with the lyrics?” Well, by the next morning, Bob had a completely different set of lyrics written with Judy Parker and the rest is history. Without the dissension between Bob and me I don't think the song would've been a hit.
Gerry Polci does the majority of the lead vocal on that and then Frankie comes in for the chorus. I also had some part of the lead. After the argument, I don't think Bob Gaudio wanted to use me at all. He worked with Gerry Polci for three solid days in the studio to get that vocal – there are a great number of splices in that lead vocal that you hear.”
Chapter image 9

Sleeve for 'December, 1963 (Oh, What a Night)'

'Slip Away' did however provide Don the chance to do a lead vocal. it allowed Don's husky voice to capture all the emotion in the lyric. It was featured 'live' throughout the year's tour and was an audience favourite.

Rex Woodard again takes up the story…..

“The 'Who Loves You' album blasted away any doubts as to the validity of the Four Seasons comeback; it was superb. The eight Bob Gaudio-Judy Parker compositions were all killers. In a radical departure, Valli only did half the lead vocals, with Ciccone and Polci executing the remainder. Several songs utilised more than one lead, with 'December '63 (Oh What A Night)' employing Polci, Ciccone and Valli. Most contemporary critics awarded the collection rave reviews.” It was released in the UK in February 1976 and climbed to #12 on the UK album charts.
Chapter image 10

On stage, 1976

Chapter image 11

Motown's 'Inside You' compilation album sleeve

Not to be outdone and ‘out of pocket’ with the cost of sessions for the huge number of unreleased and unsuccessful releases from 1971 to 1974 from a now dead contract Rex again:-

“Motown responded with its own compilation of mostly unreleased tracks titled 'Inside You'. The English 'Inside You' is the definitive version of this album, containing 12 tracks rather than the meagre nine of its American equivalent. The disc gives artist credit to just Valli although six songs (including 'Hickory', 'Charisma' and 'Walk On') are really Four Seasons recordings. Gaudio cringed when he learned of the release since he had had no role in the final mix. Still, the record stands as Valli's last predominantly falsetto collection. Motown still holds the rights to some three dozen masters as again demonstrated by its late 1980 release of yet another Four Seasons compilation.” [today we know it turned out to be over 70 session Masters recorded at Motown]

Not owning the Motown tracks meant that, although songs from this period entered the UK charts and despite the huge interest of UK fans in past tracks, Valli never performed anything from the Motown period during this revival. In fact, 'The Night' (a No 5 hit in the UK in Feb 1975) was only ever performed a few times back in 1972/73 notably at Capitol Theatre Passaic NJ March 25th 1973. By 1976 Motown was releasing music that was outside the Partnerships control and not making them money….. Bob and Frankie didn't want to go back there musically either – they had a new sound with a great group of musicians which fans world-wide had fallen in love with.

Rex Woodard again…..

“Warner-Curb took a calculated risk in December by choosing 'December 63' as its follow up single to 'Who Loves You'. Gerry Polci sings lead, with Valli only featured in the chorus. 'December 63' was pure disco and a complete stylistic change from the familiar Four Seasons sound. At the same time, Valli checked into Los Angeles Century City Hospital a week before Christmas to (prepare to) undergo a last ditch surgical procedure to save his hearing.”

In fact January 12th 1976 saw Frankie Valli once again in Century Hospital LA hospital having his second ear operation to combat Otosclerosis (a disease of the bones of the inner ear) this time on his right ear. It was said in the US newsletters

“He is wanting to tour less and spend more time producing records and doing TV/movies and spending time with his family. He sees his future as separate, but allied to that of the Four Seasons”

Rex Woodard tells us…

“The operation sidelined the group for sometime, but optimistic early medical reports promised an audible future for its leader. By March Valli was fit to resume touring, prior to the much anticipated return to the UK for a 14 date tour as the first leg of a World Tour that would take in Holland/Germany and Australia / New Zealand”

Valli spoke about how debilitating the problem had been for him personally in Crawdaddy magazine before the surgery….

“Luckily, I got a hold of myself” says Frankie “and went to see some other doctors, the best I could find, specialists. Basically, it was my left ear in particular that was bothering me, though both were affected. I can hear fine out of my left ear now but before undergoing the operation last year - I could have lost what I had – I went through a period of depression which was rather difficult for my wife Mary Ann to live with. She was super-understanding about the whole thing which made it easier. The left ear is okay now but the right ear is fading and know I have to have that taken care of”.
Goldmine: It's odd that I've never heard much about his hearing troubles before, I tell Valli. How was he able to continue making records and touring?
“Well”, he confesses, unsmiling “it hasn't been easy. In the studio, for instance, the level I had to have my headphones turned up to was extremely high. Nobody could believe that a human could listen at this level. It was so loud it was shattering. And when we did a playback, everyone had to leave the studio because they couldn't bear it.”

Meanwhile, as Rex Woodard tells us…

“'December 63' released in January tore to the top off the US national charts. The record seized the Billboard number one spot on 13 March 1976 not relinquishing the position for three weeks. Whopping sales exceeding three million copies established 'December 63' as the biggest selling Four Seasons single ever.” Also in January for the 1976 UK Tour, Private Stock released “a new Frankie Valli recording of a song written and recorded by British band 'Rogue'. The song 'Fallen Angel' (Flett/Fletcher), was produced by Bob Gaudio and arranged by Lee Shapiro.”

The UK tour was discussed by Bob Gaudio in a Record Mirror interview. He couldn't believe 'December 63' was their first No 1 in the UK….'Rag Doll' had previously only achieved No 2…..

“I'm quite surprised”, he admits, “that 'December 63' has done so well so quickly in Britain. We normally reckon we can pick out which tracks are going to be the best ones for singles but frankly I don't think we're much in touch with the pulse of the British market. After all, we haven't toured in Britain for about three years, although Frankie Valli did come over about 12 months ago”.
“The Seasons are now preparing to return to Britain after their long absence. The band are putting together a completely new show for the British tour, which runs from April 1st to 14th”, says Gaudio. “It will be quite lavish, a mild extravaganza and it's going to be quite expensive”. So you don't think it'll make money for the group? …..“I'm positive it won't. As far as we're concerned it's a freebie. It's going to be a very diversified show covering yesterday, today and tomorrow. The group will be playing all the old hits – some of them in medley form maybe, then show what they are doing right now and then give some of what's going to be happening in the future. The group will all come on together at the start and do some numbers and then Frankie will do a solo spot of around 20 minutes to half an hour before the whole group return again”.

Frankie Valli is a busy man, who has solo recording commitments – as a solo artist he's on Private Stock – as well as his work with the Four Seasons, who are on the Warner Bros label. Gaudio is equally busy since he writes both for Valli and the Seasons as a whole.

“Sometimes I can keep pace with their requirements or even get a little bit ahead, but at the moment I'm fighting to keep up. At the moment we're in the process of choosing what's going to be the next Frankie Valli single but then the next big project is Frankie's album, which will be recorded immediately after the British tour.”

The general policy is for the Four Seasons to average two albums and two singles a year and Valli likewise,

“but”, says Gaudio, “you can't stick to that rigidly. If you get a failure or two with singles you may need to put out more a year, whereas if you get a big hit in the States it can hang around for months, so you don't need to put out so many”.

The UK Tour April 1976

Chapter image 12

The Four Seasons on the 1976 UK tour programe

The group appeared on Top Of The Pops on 8th April. Introduced by Noel Edmunds a BBC DJ and big fan who had been instrumental in promoting 'Who Loves You' on his national Radio 1 Breakfast Show in 1976. They performed without Frankie Valli on 'Silver Star' and Frankie Valli performed his latest solo release 'Fallen Angel'. The tour was hugely successful and fan club membership exploded.

Chapter image 13Chapter image 14
Chapter image 15Chapter image 16

Above: Clips from the Top Of The Pops performance and below the tour brochure

Chapter image 17

The third Warner-Curb single from the album, Polci's “Silver Star” had moderate sales in the United States (#38) but huge success worldwide. It hit No 2 on 18 May in London and No 1 on Radio Luxembourg the same month. On the BBC chart it reached #3 while 'Fallen Angel/Carrie I Would Marry You' PVT51 reached #11 in March. A 40 song K-Tel collection of Four Seasons oldies hits spent much of 1976 on England's album chart, reaching the No 4 spot. The 'Who Loves You' album was also a huge success and reached Nr 16 in the UK album charts for 3 consecutive weeks in April and May. The Four Seasons Partnership had done a deal for a UK re-issue of all the past hits and the Double Album entered the BBC album charts in November and spent 5 weeks in the Top Ten.

Chapter image 18

The K-Tel 'Greatest Hits' compilation album, 1976

Then, upon Valli's return to the USA, Producer, Lou Reizner recorded the Four Seasons accompanied by the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra. The two Lennon-McCartney selections they recorded appear on the soundtrack of the movie 'All This and World War II'. Gaudio also recorded with the group in mid 1976 doing eight songs for an album due out in 1977. Billboard reported on 5th June

“The Four Seasons were touring the USA from May 20th through to October 1st (over 80 performances) and Frankie Valli was in the Sound Factory Los Angeles working on a new album. The group members backed him on several numbers as part of the orchestra. Due to be released at the beginning of September the album is called 'Valli' with 'Can't Get You Off My Mind' and 'Easily' being performed in live USA concerts”[as potential next singles]
Chapter image 19

Soundtrack sleeve for 'All This and World War II'

Chapter image 20

Sleeve for 'We Can Work It Out'

September came around and Bob Gaudio was working on Neil Diamond's latest album as producer…'I'm Glad You're Here With Me Tonight' was released by Columbia Records. October had Valli in the studio as producer. 'One Night Affair' was co-produced with Terry Randazzo with Jay Black on Roulette Records and then Frankie Valli and Four Seasons attended the opening night of the music documentary 'All This And WWII' on 11th November in Hollywood California. 'We Can Work It Out' from the movie b/w 'Harmony, Perfect Harmony' was the latest single release by the group and it entered the UK charts on 20th Nov at #53 reaching #34 for 2 consecutive weeks.

The Four Seasons then spent over 6 weeks in the Sound Factory studio LA to end the year recording their new 'Helicon' album for Warner Bros. Due out in the USA in Jan and the UK Feb the pencilled single was 'If We Should Lose Our Love'. Valli would only sing lead on 3 of the 10 tracks and on two this was a shared lead with Don and Gerry.

The album tracks when presented to the Warner-Curb execs drew the comment….” We don't hear a single” so accordingly a more commercial song was written by Bob Gaudio and Judy Parker to appease the company. 'Down The Hall' was developed “around the piano” according to John Paiva and quickly recorded and added to the album. 'Rhapsody', a potential album title was not considered strong enough.

The group were in great demand and recorded the Dick Clark New Years Rockin' Eve Show on Dec 15th (for showing on New Years Eve) and the group featured on 3 songs without Frankie Valli….including the then unreleased 'If We Should Lose Our Love.'

In what was turning out to be a whirlwind year, 'December 63' went platinum selling over 3m (Record World) making it the biggest ever seller in the Four Seasons 14 year career. It reached Nr 10 in the BBC chart of the best selling singles of the year…in the USA it was #4. Record sales continued to be phenomenal with Private Stock's 'Four Seasons Story' going 'Gold' in the UK.

Chapter image 21

Frankie Valli's December 1976 UK solo EP

A Valli solo EP was released on Dec 2nd 1976 in the UK featuring 'Boomerang' and 'Swearin' To God' B/W 'My Eyes Adored You' and 'Fallen Angel'

The group was positive re their own future in an interview with Brian Gari for The Entertainment Spectrum in the same month.

“Spectrum: Lee……You arranged all the medleys that are performed on stage and even some dynamite instrumentals like 'The Warsaw Concerto'. Have these instrumentals ever been recorded and, if so, will they be released?
Lee Shapiro:'Brian's Song' got recorded, but never got released. 'The Warsaw Concerto' was going to be recorded and come out under a new group name, somewhat along the lines of what was done during the mid-sixties with The Seasons, but because of some legalities, it never saw the light of day.
Spectrum: Aside from your fine arranging abilities you are showing great promise in becoming a successful composer. What are your plans in that direction?
Lee Shapiro: Well, Don Ciccone and I have written several songs together that have been getting some very good response; 'Carrie (I Would Marry You)' was, of course, recorded by Frankie and we have a couple more that we think would be right for him. I've also written with other people and have started a publishing and production firm. Don and I both together and individually, want to get into more record production.
Chapter image 22

John Paiva and Lee Shapiro on stage 1976. Photo courtesy of John Paiva

Spectrum: Don ?... Are you writing songs now with the Seasons in mind?
Don Ciccone: As a matter of fact, the group's success has inspired many new songs, several of which were written specifically with Frankie in mind. Lee and I are in the process of finishing up some demonstration tapes on these tunes and hope they'll be finding their way into future releases.
Spectrum: Gerry ?.... Being the first singer to ever share the solo spotlight with Frankie on record, where do you think the Four Seasons will go from here?
Gerry Polci: I personally feel the Seasons will go solo. From what I understand, Don and I will be sharing the lead vocals while Frankie continues with his solo records.
Spectrum: Do you think there will be a need for an image change?
Gerry Polci: I definitely feel the Seasons without Frankie Valli will not be totally accepted until we have at least three solo hits in a row. I think we should get into a more FM progressive direction; not like Elton John or Earth Wind and Fire, but I suppose more like a Grand Funk. I'd like the group to be considered good listening rock utilizing arps. It's kind of a long range process, but I'm certainly happy where we are now.
Spectrum: Whose material do you think would be appropriate for the new Seasons?
Gerry Polici: I think Don and Lee are writing some great material. Their songs might be exactly the right creative direction for the group.”

Frankie Valli had told audiences of the plans for an instrumental album during the 1976 tour…..but as Lee recently explained this was not possible.

“An exec from Private Stock heard us do 'The Warsaw Concerto' arrangement and asked me if we could sign for an album of instrumentals. I told him we couldn't as we were signed to the Partnership and they had signed the group exclusively to Warner-Curb. So although it would have been nice, legal complexities meant it was impossible………and, yes we did do some writing together in the hope it would be good enough for a future album”.

Fortunately, in 2009 John Paiva supplied a cassette tape containing 4 demos have survived from this period. 'Day To Day', 'Funny How A Honey Can Be', 'Free Ride' and 'I Was Better Off'“ along with ‘Brian’s Song’ and ‘The Warsaw Concerto’ . Only the last two made it onto the Snapper Box Set, but the others can be heard on the embedded links in the titles on my ‘MowestChameleon’ You Tube page. These show the great potential this band had.

The bands solo aspirations in 1976 had been proven and their ambitions were being accepted by Frankie and Bob. 1977 would be the year to prove they could achieve that. But the winds of change were blowing through the music industry and their impact would be disastrous for some record companies, the group and the fans.

The Four Seasons, 1976

Chapter image 23

Chapter References/Credits

Goldmine Article – The Four Seasons - A Lesson in Survival by Rex Woodard 1981: Article From A Warner Bros Circular November 1984 by Joshua Baer Titled “4 Seasons To Consider”; “Out Of Season” by John Paiva (unpublished biography); Four Seasons UK Appreciation Society Newsletters: Brian Gari for The Entertainment Spectrum Dec 1976: Special thanks to: Charles Calello: Lee Shapiro: Frank Rovello: Ken Charmer: George Ingram: Lynn Boleyn: Ray Nichol: